Call Us – We’re Easy to Talk To
(214) 999-9999

Elder Law • Medicaid Planning • VA Benefits

FDA Proposes New Warnings for Cigarette Packs

Jan 14, 2020

There is extensive coverage of an announcement by the FDA regarding proposed new warnings for cigarette packages. The agency says the warnings are an essential method of communicating the dangers of smoking to the public, but some anti-smoking advocates are concerned the industry will launch another round of legal battles to prevent the changes.

The New York Times reports that “nine years after the Food and Drug Administration first proposed graphic images as warnings on cigarette packs but was thwarted by tobacco companies in a successful court battle, the agency announced on Thursday that it is finally issuing a new set.” Every one “of the 13 proposed warnings would cover the top half of a cigarette pack, to be used in rotation by manufacturers along with a variety of updated statements about the health risks of smoking.” Mitchell Zeller, “who runs the F.D.A.’s tobacco division,” said in a media call, “When you look at the current warnings on the side of cigarette packs, they are virtually invisible. … The diseases embedded in these images will improve public understanding of the negative consequences of cigarette smoking.” Acting FDA Commissioner Ned Sharpless said in a news release, “While most people assume the public knows all they need to understand about the harms of cigarette smoking, there’s a surprising number of lesser-known risks that both youth and adult smokers and nonsmokers may simply not be aware of.” Former FDA tobacco lawyer Eric Lindblom said, “The F.D.A. lawyers, the health and human services lawyers, the Department of Justice lawyers, they are all scared of any F.D.A. issue that raises First Amendment issues because they lost big [in a 2012 court ruling over such images], and they don’t want to lose again.”

The Wall Street Journal reports that the proposed warnings include images of feet with amputated toes and a tumor on a person’s neck.

The AP reports “other color illustrations would warn smokers that cigarettes can cause heart disease, impotence and diabetes.” The new “labels would take up half of the front of cigarette packages and include text warnings, such as ‘Smoking causes head and neck cancer.’” The warning “labels would also appear on tobacco advertisements.” Zeller is quoted as saying, “While the public generally understands that cigarette smoking is dangerous, there are significant gaps in their understanding of all of the diseases and conditions associated with smoking.” Zeller added that “we strongly believe this will hold up under any legal challenges.”

Reuters reports “the new proposal follows a failed bid by the FDA in 2011 for colored graphic warnings, which was challenged in court by tobacco companies and ultimately declined in 2012.” Zeller said during a media call, “We learned a lot from what happened the last time around, and took the time through the research to get this right.”

Politico reports “the rule must be finalized by March and would go into effect 15 months later, FDA officials said.” The article says “commenters have two months to offer suggestions on the rule.” The “images that FDA would require cigarette packages to bear will depict some of the lesser-known but serious health risks of smoking, said… Sharpless.” The agency “has been researching how to shape the package messages for six years, said Mitch Zeller.” Politico adds that the White House and HHS “were ‘very supportive of our efforts,’ [Sharpless] said.”

CNN reports on its website that the new health warnings would occupy “at least 20% of the area at the top of cigarette ads, according to the FDA.” Sharpless is quoted as saying, “With these new proposed cigarette health warnings, we have an enormous public health opportunity to fulfill our statutory mandate and increase the public’s understanding of the full scope of serious negative health consequences of cigarette smoking. … Given that tobacco use is still the leading cause of preventable disease and death in the U.S., there’s a lot at stake to ensure the public understands these risks.”

From the news release of the American Association for Justice.

Topics

Archives

elder law attorney, estate planning, asset protection, medicaid planning, va benefits

Since starting his practice of law in 1971 Mr. Kraft has helped many thousands of people address their concerns and achieve their goals. He is committed to giving seniors and the people who love them information to cope with living and aging.

Contact us to see how we can help!